Liu Yao vs Qimen Dunjia

Direct answer

Liu Yao uses a vertical six-line hexagram chart; Qimen Dunjia uses a time-and-space board with palaces and multiple symbols. Their inputs, data structures, and question granularity differ even when both include stems and branches. The page distinguishes reproducible structure from conditional interpretation and gives one concrete check that can be independently repeated.

Definitions and prerequisites

Before applying the rule, preserve the bounded question, six bottom-up line values, casting time, timezone, day-boundary policy, and named source convention. If an input is missing, stop at definition rather than filling the gap symbolically. Liu Yao uses a vertical six-line hexagram chart; Qimen Dunjia uses a time-and-space board with palaces and multiple symbols. Their inputs, data structures, and question granularity differ even when both include stems and branches.

Method or reference rule

Use this auditable procedure: Compare cast versus calendrical input, six positions versus nine palaces, Najia relations versus Qimen layers, and each product’s deterministic contract. A shared Han term does not authorize cross-system substitution. Save the input, intermediate rows, applicable source locator, product version, and any uncertainty before weighing an interpretive effect.

Worked example

Worked check: A Liu Yao line can carry a Najia stem-branch and Six Relative. A Qimen palace can contain stems, star, door, deity, and other board relations; copying one label across loses its structural owner. Save the input, intermediate rows, applicable source locator, product version, and any uncertainty before weighing an interpretive effect.

Closest failure case

The closest failure case for Liu Yao vs Qimen Dunjia is to retain its memorable label while dropping the inputs, direction, source rule, or conflicting evidence. That shortcut cannot be reproduced and can turn a conditional classification into an unsupported prediction.

Sources, interpretation and limits

Liu Yao uses a vertical six-line hexagram chart; Qimen Dunjia uses a time-and-space board with palaces and multiple symbols. Their inputs, data structures, and question granularity differ even when both include stems and branches. Keep fixed chart output, attributed historical rules, editorial interpretation, and real-world evidence in separate layers. This reference cannot establish hidden thoughts, causation, or a guaranteed future outcome; medical, legal, financial, and safety decisions require direct evidence and qualified help.

Chinese, Japanese and Korean records show overlapping local labels. A shared catalogue entry is terminology evidence, not proof that every lineage uses the words identically.

Verification checklist

Save the question, cast time, timezone, face convention, six line values, source edition and product version whenever they can change the result.

• Reproduce the six stored line values before interpretation.
• Name the method, edition and product settings used.
• Cite the decisive chart facts instead of one dramatic label.
• Use observable records and qualified advice for high-stakes decisions.

Related next step

Follow the parent and related-page cards for the next defined task. Use the OpenFate Liu Yao tool to generate a replayable chart; do not treat the tool as proof of an outcome.