Combination and Clash Appearing Together (合沖並見)
Understand how valid combinations and clashes coexist, compete, redirect force, or act in separate areas without automatic cancellation.
Overview
合沖並見 records valid combination and clash relations appearing together. They may compete for one participant, affect different branches, or change priority across timing layers. Detection, topology, completion, season, roots, proximity, repetition, and damage determine whether combination dominates, clash dominates, both divide force, or both remain independently active.
At a glance
- Required evidence
- At least one valid combination and one valid clash
- Topology question
- Shared participant or separate relation zones
- Priority evidence
- Completion, season, roots, proximity, repetition, damage, and timing
- Possible result
- Combination-led, clash-led, divided, redirected, or independent
- Layer rule
- Priority can change when timed branches arrive or leave
- Boundary
- The pair of labels does not predict relational instability
Map each valid relation before resolving it
Name the exact combination pair or group and the exact Six-Clash pair.
Show whether they share a participant; separate zones do not require mutual cancellation.
- Validate each edge.
- Identify shared topology.
Compare completed and usable force
A nominal combination should not automatically defeat a rooted, repeated clash.
A complete, seasonally supported group may bind or redirect a weaker clash, but residual force remains reportable.
- Use symmetrical criteria.
- Keep residual status.
Recalculate when timing changes the network
A Luck Pillar or year can complete a combination, introduce a clash, or remove the temporary participant later.
Publish the baseline, active-period result, and post-period return separately.
- Version the relation state.
- Date every temporary edge.
Avoid love-hate and event narratives
合沖並見 cannot by itself prove an unstable relationship, reconciliation, relocation, accident, or career change.
It describes competing structural routes; practical meaning depends on roles, choices, and real evidence.
- No relationship cliché.
- No event certainty.
Sources and editorial basis
- 《三命通會》 (Sanming Tonghui)《三命通會》六合六沖及合化諸例：合沖可同時成立，結果隨共享成員、得令、位置及沖破而變A historical compilation covering stems and branches, Ten Gods, Nayin, Shen Sha, and multiple classical pattern systems.
- 《淵海子平》 (Yuanhai Ziping)《淵海子平》合沖諸論：相合可能牽制、重定向或與沖並存，不能預設互相完全抵銷A foundational Ziping reference for branch months, hidden stems, roots, and stem-branch relationships.
- OpenFate Editorial Methodology合沖並見頁分別計算兩條關係後再解析優先度，保留未被充分解釋的殘餘作用OpenFate separates deterministic chart calculation, traditional interpretation, and modern editorial explanation.